The 2025-26 Premier League season was a rollercoaster of emotions, with each team experiencing highs and lows. From the thrilling triumphs to the crushing defeats, every moment was a testament to the beauty and unpredictability of the beautiful game. As we reflect on the season, it's clear that the league is more competitive than ever, with several teams pushing for European places and others fighting to avoid relegation. The stars of the season shone brightly, while the flops struggled to find their footing. Here's a look at the verdicts from the fans, with a focus on Arsenal, Aston Villa, Bournemouth, Brentford, Brighton, Burnley, Chelsea, Crystal Palace, Everton, Fulham, Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester City, Manchester United, Newcastle, Nottingham Forest, Sunderland, Tottenham, West Ham, and Wolves.
Arsenal: The Gunners had a remarkable season, finishing in the top four and securing a spot in the Champions League. The defense was rock solid, with Raya, Gabriel, Saliba, and Rice forming an impenetrable wall. However, Martinelli's lack of goals and Madueke's inconsistent form were areas of concern. The team's ability to defend and counter-attack effectively was a key strength, and the fans were proud of the 'process' that led to the title.
Stars/Flops: Raya, Gabriel, Saliba, and Rice were the stars, while Martinelli and Madueke were the flops.
What we need in the summer: To strengthen the attack and add depth to the squad.
Best/Worst away fans: Atlético Madrid's fans were the best, while Spurs fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: The unbridled joy of the celebrations in the streets around Highbury, and the exposure of Hincapié's backside against Burnley.
Aston Villa: Unai Emery's team had a brilliant season, culminating in a joyous party in Istanbul. The connection between the players and the fans was strong, and the team's ability to perform when it mattered was legendary. The season was a success, and the fans were proud of their team.
Stars/Flops: McGinn and Konsa were the stars, while Carlos Baleba was a disappointment.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and replace some of the deadwood.
Best/Worst away fans: Liverpool and Maccabi Tel Aviv fans were the best, while Sunderland fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Buendía's winner against Arsenal and the subsequent pitch-pounding.
Bournemouth: The Cherries had an astonishing season, finishing in the top ten and securing a spot in Europe. The team's energy, excitement, and fearlessness were a joy to watch, and the fans were proud of their achievement.
Stars/Flops: Alex Scott, Junior Kroupi, Rayan, Truffert, Senesi, Tavernier, Adam Smith, Tyler Adams, and Petrovic were the stars, while James Hill was the top choice.
What we need in the summer: To strengthen the squad and improve contracts for the stars.
Best/Worst away fans: Leeds fans were the best, while Noel Gallagher was the worst.
Moment that made me smile: The final whistle against Man City and the tears of joy.
Brentford: Thomas Frank's team had a great season, finishing in the top ten and securing a spot in Europe. The fans were proud of their achievement, and the team's ability to compete with the big boys was a testament to their hard work.
Stars/Flops: Igor Thiago and Michael Kayode were the stars, while Kevin Schade was a disappointment.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and replace Wissa.
Best/Worst away fans: Wolves fans were the best, while Fulham fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Igor Thiago's family reacting to his first Brazil call-up.
Brighton: The Albion had a strange season, finishing in the top ten and securing a spot in Europe. The team's ability to bounce back from a poor winter was a testament to their resilience, and the fans were proud of their achievement.
Stars/Flops: Ferdi Kadioglu was a revelation, while Carlos Baleba was a disappointment.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and improve the full-back cover.
Best/Worst away fans: Sunderland fans were the best, while Chelsea fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: David Raya landing on his shoulder and writhing around in pain.
Burnley: The Clarets had a disastrous season, finishing in the bottom three and being relegated. The team's inability to win enough points was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Zian Flemming scored 10 Premier League goals, while Kyle Walker was a disappointment.
What we need in the summer: A new manager and an overhaul of the recruitment department.
Best/Worst away fans: Sunderland and Villa fans were the best, while Leeds fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Sean Dyche's sudden love of social media.
Chelsea: The Blues had a disastrous season, losing two managers and struggling with form. The fans were disappointed with the results, and the team's inability to perform consistently was a concern.
Stars/Flops: João Pedro was the most consistent player, while the defense collectively flopped.
What we need in the summer: To sign an experienced quality centre-back, a top goalkeeper, and another top striker.
Best/Worst away fans: Port Vale fans were the best, while Arsenal fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Cole Palmer's look of surprise during the infamous huddle.
Crystal Palace: The Eagles had a rollercoaster season, finishing in the top ten and securing a spot in Europe. The team's ability to bounce back from setbacks was a testament to their resilience, and the fans were proud of their achievement.
Stars/Flops: Ismaïla Sarr was the player of the season, while Yeremy Pino struggled for confidence.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and improve the squad depth.
Best/Worst away fans: Leeds fans were the best, while Burnley fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Palace Women's promotion to the WSL and the FA Youth Cup semi-finals.
Everton: The Toffees had a frustrating season, finishing in the middle of the table and missing out on European places. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Ndiaye and Dewsbury-Hall were the stars, while Dibling and McNeil were the flops.
What we need in the summer: To sign two full-backs, another central defender, and more quality up front.
Best/Worst away fans: Sunderland fans were the best, while our neighbours were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: November's Gueye/Keane slap at Old Trafford.
Fulham: The Cottagers had a consistently inconsistent season, finishing in the middle of the table. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Wilson and Sessegnon were the stars, while Andersen and Robinson failed to shine post-injury.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and replace Silva if he leaves.
Best/Worst away fans: Sunderland, Wolves, Palace, and Newcastle fans were the best, while Brentford fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Special agent Rosenior at work and the Jean Tigana reunion evening.
Leeds: The Whites had a near-miss season, finishing in the middle of the table and missing out on European places. The team's ability to compete with the big boys was a testament to their hard work, and the fans were proud of their achievement.
Stars/Flops: Dominic Calvert-Lewin, Gabriel Gudmundsson, James Justin, Anton Stach, Ethan Ampadu, and Karl Darlow were the stars, while Lucas Perri's hair transplant was a roaring success.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and improve the squad depth.
Best/Worst away fans: All the away fans were equally the best and worst.
Moment that made me smile: The view of our second goal at Old Trafford and Bruno Fernandes' fake injury.
Liverpool: The Reds had a frustrating season, finishing in the middle of the table and missing out on European places. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Rio Ngumoha and Dominik Szoboszlai were the stars, while the defense and midfield needed improvement.
What we need in the summer: To reset, find consistency, and play as a team again.
Best/Worst away fans: Crystal Palace fans were the best, while Liverpool fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: The Marseille tifo of the Beatles and the winner away at Hill Dickinson.
Manchester City: The Citizens had a great season, finishing in the top four and securing a spot in the Champions League. The team's ability to perform consistently was a testament to their hard work, and the fans were proud of their achievement.
Stars/Flops: O'Reilly, Doku, and Nunes were the stars, while Reijnders and Savinho were the flops.
What we need in the summer: To replace Pep and add depth to the squad.
Best/Worst away fans: Sunderland fans were the best, while Wolves fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Guardiola's send-off at the Etihad.
Manchester United: The Red Devils had a season of two halves, finishing in the middle of the table and missing out on European places. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Mainoo's revival under Carrick and Lammens were the positives, while Mount disappeared with injuries.
What we need in the summer: To add athleticism in midfield and sign another striker.
Best/Worst away fans: Wolves fans were the best, while Liverpool fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: The breaking news that Amorim had gone.
Newcastle: The Magpies had a tough season, finishing in the middle of the table and missing out on European places. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Will Osula, Lewis Hall, and Malick Thiaw were the stars, while Yoanne Wissa and Anthony Elanga were the flops.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and reshape the forward line.
Best/Worst away fans: Bradford City fans were the best, while Manchester United fans were the worst.
Moment that made us smile: Arne Slot's comment about Isak and Murphy.
Nottingham Forest: The Reds had a disastrous season, finishing in the bottom three and being relegated. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Elliot Anderson and Neco Williams were the stars, while Dan Ndoye was a disappointment.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and improve the squad depth.
Best/Worst away fans: Fenerbahce fans were the best, while Burnley fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Poor Omari Hutchinson's face cream comment.
Sunderland: The Black Cats had a great season, finishing in the top ten and securing a spot in Europe. The team's ability to compete with the big boys was a testament to their hard work, and the fans were proud of their achievement.
Stars/Flops: Granit Xhaka and Chris Rigg were the stars, while Eliezer Mayenda and Habib Diarra struggled for rhythm.
What we need this summer: To add quality without losing what has made this work.
Best/Worst away fans: Spurs fans were the best, while Brentford fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: Beating the Mags away and the joy of the fans.
Tottenham: The Spurs had a disastrous season, finishing in the bottom three and being relegated. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Everything has flopped, and the squad needs gutting.
What we need in the summer: To let De Zerbi have full control and improve the squad depth.
Best/Worst away fans: Every set of away fans were equally the best and worst.
Moment that made me smile: The breaking news that Frank had gone and Tudor had been appointed.
West Ham: The Hammers had a stress-inducing season, finishing in the middle of the table and missing out on European places. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Jarrod Bowen, 'Jimmy' Summerville, Fernandes, and Dinos Mavropanos were the stars, while Max Kilman and Pablo were the flops.
What we need in the summer: To sign Disasi and a striker if relegated, and improve the squad depth if we stay up.
Best/Worst away fans: Best were Wolves for their gallows humour, while worst were Chelsea for their chants of 'Three more years Graham Potter'.
Moment that made me smile: Mikel Arteta's protection of goalkeepers and David Squires' cartoon.
Wolves: The Wolves had a disastrous season, finishing in the bottom three and being relegated. The team's inability to perform consistently was a concern, and the fans were disappointed with the results.
Stars/Flops: Jhon Arias and Fer López were the flops, while Mateus Mané provided a beacon of hope for next season.
What we need in the summer: To add depth to the squad and sign a captain.
Best/Worst away fans: Bournemouth fans were the best, while Wolves fans were the worst.
Moment that made me smile: None.
